Online Now 1270

Get 30 days FREE to AuburnUndercover

Get VIP access to all AU recruiting updatesClick here to get started

Phillip's blog: Troubled times

Even 20 years ago, no one could have imagined what we have come to in college football in our state and beyond.

Phillip Lolley

Senior Editor Phillip Marshall

Anyone can be a blogger or even start a web site, declare himself a reporter and go in search of page views. The more outlandish the “reporting,” the more viewers come to look. Some of these guys know just enough about NCAA rules, how to search the Internet and how to get public records to be dangerous.

They search message boards, once dismissed as nothing more than fan chatter. Conspiracy theories abound on some of those boards, and sometimes they end up on those web sites or in those blogs and eventually make their way to more reputable news outlets.

It takes reading no more than a few paragraphs of most of those conspiracy theories to recognize that they couldn’t possibly be true. But they spread and grow like weeds anyway.

An oddsmaker can go on a radio show, claim to have a source at the NCAA, change his story to say he has a source who has a source in the NCAA, and create a national stir.

With that as a backdrop, it is my heart-felt opinion that we have come to a college football crisis in the state of Alabama. If it’s not someway, somehow brought under control, this might be remembered as the last great era of college football in a state where it means so much.

I’m not talking about fans who are passionate for their school or even passionate in their dislike for the opposing school. The word “hate” gets thrown around, but most of the time it’s not really hate. You saw that with the unified response to the tragic tornadoes that hit our state.

I’m not talking about using words like Barners and Bammers. I don’t have any problem with a fan wearing a “I hate Auburn (or Alabama)” t-shirt. Those kinds of things are harmless and have always been part of the rivalry.

This crisis isn’t about any of those things. It’s about very real efforts to destroy the other side.

For months, there has been a widespread message board campaign to convince the world that Auburn’s national championship is tainted at best, temporary at worst. It certainly has been successful in convincing a lot of people who don’t know better. Now we are starting to see signs of retaliation from the Auburn side. No one cares who gets hurt, as long as he wears the colors of the other team.

In this day of instant information, there are lots of eyes watching every college football program. And behind some of those eyes are people who rejoice in anything bad that happens to the other side or anyone associated with the other side. Combine them with amateur reporters who have suddenly gained notoriety, and you have a very bad mixture.

Word is that the NCAA has received an unprecedented number of emails, faxes, etc., from Alabama fans claiming Auburn is dirty. Like-minded Auburn fans aren’t going to take it lying down, so now they’re doing all they can to fight back.

Auburn coach Gene Chizik said Thursday that, if the fans would respect each other as much as the players and coaches, there wouldn’t be any problems. Alabama coach Nick Saban said similar things Friday. Was anyone listening?

Probably not.

What’s it going to take to turn down the volume? Is it going to take both programs going down in flames? If you don’t think that can happen, check out the old Southwest Conference. Is it going to someone being killed?

I don’t know those answers, but I know at a time when the focus should be on celebrating the last two national champions and last two Heisman Trophy winners residing in this state, the atmosphere is toxic and getting worse.

Phillip Marshall is a senior editor for AuburnUndercover

    • Well said

        aucivil

      • This post is for members of AuburnUndercover only. Join now!30-day Free Trial!

          AUwardeagle

          • Avatar
        • Amen! I don't post much but EVERYBODY needs to remember these are 18 year old kids that the vast majority of us don't even know whose lives and reputation are being destroyed over a game. No matter what color uniform they wear no one should get pleasure from the downfall of one of these kids. It doesn't make it right just because someone else started it.

            wareagle123

          • AMEN, Phillip!!

              Skooks

              • Avatar
            • This post is for members of AuburnUndercover only. Join now!30-day Free Trial!

                TigerzBaby

                • Avatar
              • The speed in which technology is changing the way we are communicating with one another is astounding. While growing up and being educated in Alabama (1950's), football was just a diversion, albeit an important diversion. Reading the Sunday morning newspaper (The Birmingham News) was a weekly ritual. We got our stories through very professional filters, particularly Benny Marshall and some others. Now, there are "no filters" and we're getting bombarded every day with fringe demagogues whose sole purpose is to rant about their sports theology and denigrate the opposition, particularly when it comes to football....Alabama football. Most likely, these idiots are not remotely associated (alumni nor significant contributors) with the universities for which they profess their love and devotion. They attach their life's meaning and self worth with "their" team, where "feeling good" at all cost becomes their mantra. The internet is their conduit for self fulfillment and when things aren't going well, whatever restores their sense of well being, we're going to hear. Never mind the truth or any sense of balance; let's make stuff up and see what sticks (and absorb the fifteen minutes of fame). The fringe group has always been there, it's just that there were filters in place so their message never migrated. So, how do you stop this destructive train wreck from happening? It's difficult, but, identify the fringe parties, isolate them, don't read or buy their theology, boycott their sponsors and never remain silent.

                This post has been edited 2 times, most recently by jcooley on 7/23/2011 at 1:30 PM

                  jcooley

                • Phillip, I joined this site because of your integrity, insights, talent for writing and passion for Auburn football. You never let us down. Good writing! I remember reading your dad's articles. You are a chip off the old block.... Thanks for telling like it is...

                    CoachGeorge

                  • This post is for members of AuburnUndercover only. Join now!30-day Free Trial!

                      PhillipMarshall

                      • Avatar
                      • Badge
                    • Agree Phillip......You see it posted on this board also...One side or the other has got to take the high road as you put it and stay the course in hopes the other will follow. If Auburn people really believe in the "AUBURN CREED" it will be AUBURN that takes the lead. I love the rivalry but I'am sick of this. I know what the other side has done and is doing. It's not the first time. That's been well documented but I have felt for some time what Phillip expressed in his post. The clock is ticking and that is a concern....

                        Topcat

                      • If all Auburn fans live the Auburn Creed, then we are doing our part in keeping our rivalies in perspective. It often requires "turning the other cheek", especially in these times as outined in PM's article. Living the Auburn Creed with our thoughts, words, and actions is a character trait that many will never understand except those members of our "All in Family".

                          warsameagle

                          • Avatar
                        • This post is for members of AuburnUndercover only. Join now!30-day Free Trial!

                            jmj120

                            • Avatar
                          • This post is for members of AuburnUndercover only. Join now!30-day Free Trial!

                              TigerzBaby

                              • Avatar
                            • This post is for members of AuburnUndercover only. Join now!30-day Free Trial!

                                Gadwall

                                • Avatar
                              • This post is for members of AuburnUndercover only. Join now!30-day Free Trial!

                                  19auburn49

                                  • Avatar
                                • This post is for members of AuburnUndercover only. Join now!30-day Free Trial!

                                    jmj120

                                    • Avatar
                                  • This post is for members of AuburnUndercover only. Join now!30-day Free Trial!

                                      PhillipMarshall

                                      • Avatar
                                      • Badge
                                    • Auburn sometimes seems like the kid Ralphie in "A Christmas Story" who is taunted and picked on by red-headed (Crimson-headed?) Scott Farkas over and over until he snaps, then decides he's not going to take it anymore and wails on him. I think the "rivalry" is out of control, but only because we see it as a rivalry and Bama sees us as an enemy they are actively trying to destroy.

                                        McLagman

                                        • Avatar
                                      • I see the point, but if AU doesn't violate any rules then we have nothing to worry about

                                          berryps

                                          • Avatar
                                        • I would also add that when Bear Byrant kept the NFL out of Birmingham, he doomed this state to third-world mediocrity, while Atlanta turned itself into a world class city. I don't think anyone loves UGA any less because Atlanta has the Falcons. And once you have an NFL team, then it creates a feedback effect where you can grow big businesses (Delta, Coke, CNN,), concerts, restaurants, Olympics, etc. In Alabama, the moron Bama fans decided that all this state will ever have is Bama football. It's July and Bama fans are arguing football games from last fall. This is what we get, and it will never change.

                                            McLagman

                                            • Avatar
                                          • Philip - do you have any sense as to how many emails Bama fans sent to the NCAA or the scale of what they did? I think this sounds similar to them flooding the SEC office with complaints about Nick Fairley that led to the call in the Iron Bowl that almost cost us a shot at the NC.

                                              McLagman

                                              • Avatar
                                            • Phillip, sometime AUC has to do more than critic the hatred that flows between UAT and AU. You and Bryan Mathews are regarded universally throughout the fan base. Doing more to show the regard that players have for each other might be a good start. Coach Saban may not be a likeable person, but I doubt that the snide remarks thrown his way are completely devoid of ill will. What more can be done is way beyond my scale of intellect, but allowing people to refer to our friends and rightuous opponents as "turds" hardly help matters. I may set a record of down votes with this, but to be honest with you, I don't give a s--t. I'd like to see the hate disappear because I have reason to highly regard both UAT and API (Auburn). The gift of life handed to me from both Universities is hard to overlook. If you think this is merely drama, forget it. I haven't lived in a completely safe sphere my 85 years.

                                                AU49

                                              • I may be wrong, and I know we have fans that contribute to the ruckus, but I think this rivalry turned when a certain team was no longer in control of it.

                                                When Coach Dye came on board and moved the game to home and home it was the beginning of the end for bama. Then the last 11 years have been more than they can swallow.

                                                Finebaum plays to the masses simply because of the economic gain he recieves from it. He makes it clear the only reason for the shows success is because of bama. He's making megabucks and he could care less what he contributes to the rivalry.

                                                Even so, I think the fact that AU is now one of the "Hot Programs" in America is more than bama can handle.

                                                It was a good rivalry when only one team was in control. Those days are gone for them.

                                                  AUfanmsc

                                                  • Avatar
                                                • AU49 said...

                                                  Phillip, sometime AUC has to do more than critic the hatred that flows between UAT and AU. You and Bryan Mathews are regarded universally throughout the fan base. Doing more to show the regard that players have for each other might be a good start. Coach Saban may not be a likeable person, but I doubt that the snide remarks thrown his way are completely devoid of ill will. What more can be done is way beyond my scale of intellect, but allowing people to refer to our friends and rightuous opponents as "turds" hardly help matters. I may set a record of down votes with this, but to be honest with you, I don't give a s--t. I'd like to see the hate disappear because I have reason to highly regard both UAT and API (Auburn). The gift of life handed to me from both Universities is hard to overlook. If you think this is merely drama, forget it. I haven't lived in a completely safe sphere my 85 years.

                                                  They killed our Toomer's Trees, called our Tigerettes whores, had their gambling shill Danny Sheridan just trash us on national radio, tried to get Cam Newton ineligible, are trying to get our NC taken away, and are actively trying to destroy us, and you want Auburn to act nice? The problem is NOT that Auburn people aren't acting nice enough. I think we have acted nice and I think the overwhelming majority of the hate is flowing from the other side. It's not even within the same universe to think that Auburn fans acted this way after Bama won the NC in 2009.

                                                  This post has been edited 3 times, most recently by McLagman on 7/23/2011 at 3:02 PM

                                                    McLagman

                                                    • Avatar
                                                  • McLagman said...

                                                    They killed our Toomer's Trees, called our Tigerettes whores, had their gambling shill Jackie Sherril just trash us on national radio, tried to get Cam Newton ineligible, are trying to get our NC taken away, and are actively trying to destroy us, and you want Auburn to act nice? The problem is NOT that Auburn people aren't acting nice enough. I think we have acted nice and I think the overwhelming majority of the hate is flowing from the other side. It's not even within the same universe to think that Auburn fans acted this way after Bama won the NC in 2009.

                                                    I wish everybody would act nice. I wish everybody would see that trying to hurt 20-year-olds who happen to play for another team is the wrong thing to do. I said in the blog, I don't know the answer. I do know that retaliation brings more retaliation and on and on. I agree that one side can't continuously attack the other side and expect no response. I also know that most people - on both sides - don't do that. Mainly, I know that what's happening now, if it's not brought under control, is very, very bad for both programs.

                                                    This post was edited by PhillipMarshall on 7/23/2011 at 2:58 PM

                                                      PhillipMarshall

                                                      • Avatar
                                                      • Badge

                                                  Already have an account? Sign In

                                                  Add a comment
                                                  Want to be involved in the discussion?30-Day Free Trial!